Who Cares and How Much?
VHS Colour Sound 1985 20:00
Summary: The community video, produced by the filmmaking collective Barefoot Video in 1985 in Brighton & Hove, directed by Su Braden, critically examines the shortcomings of the government’s community care policies through interviews with service users, nurses, policymakers, elders in care homes, and carers.
Title number: 21503
LSA ID: LSA/28206
Description: Shot in a static, single-camera setup, the documentary intercuts interviews with illustrative footage of care homes. The film highlights key concerns such as funding cuts, the strain on domiciliary services, and the growing reliance on private care homes. Julia Cumberlege, chairwoman of Brighton Health Authority, addresses the shortfall of domiciliary services and proposed expansions, while David Howe of Brighton Health Authority speaks on budget cuts and long waiting lists. Ken Young, director of East Sussex Social Services, discusses the public, private, and voluntary balance in care provision, noting the strain on the small workforce to inspect rest homes—emphasized by a title card revealing that just five registration officers oversee 8,000 beds in East Sussex.
The documentary captures the testimonies of both carers and those receiving care. It highlights the pressures faced by elderly caregivers, with 50% looking after a relative over 65 and many struggling with their own health. A woman in her 80s recounts caring for her aunt in her 90s, while a young local authority home worker laments the lack of daycare services. The elderly recount their own experiences—an elderly woman describes suffering from malnutrition and hypothermia before moving into residential care, whereas a man in a private care home speaks positively about his placement. The video raises questions of choice, with a title card asking, "Do Elderly People Really Have a Choice?" as Ken Young discusses disparities in care quality based on financial means. The final interviews expose systemic limitations, as David Howe acknowledges the NHS's inability to fully meet demand and a home worker critiques the tendency to place individuals in profit-driven institutions rather than genuine communities. Ultimately, the documentary drives home the point that community care is impossible without greater government funding for care services.
Credits: Braden, Su (Director); Butt, Ginny (Producer); Hartley, Julie (Producer); Fifer, Lorraine (Producer); Parker, Peter (Producer); Grivell, Paul (Producer); Reynolds, Stephanie (Producer); Robertson, Kate (Producer)
Cast: Cumberlege, Julia, Chairwoman of the Brighton Health Authority
Howe, David, Member of Brighton Health Authority
Young, Ken, Director of East Sussex Social Services
Further information: London Community Video Archive collects, preserves, and shares community videos made in the 1970s and 80s in London and the South East.
Portable video recording - now a technology found in most smartphones - became available for the very first time back in the early 1970s, making it possible for individuals and communities to make their own television. The medium was taken up by people previously ignored or under-represented in the mainstream media - tenants on housing estates, community action groups, women, Black and global majority ethnic groups, young people, LGBTQIA+ people, and disabled people.
With an overriding commitment to social empowerment and to combating exclusion, 'community video' dealt with issues which still have a contemporary resonance - housing, play-space, discrimination, and youth arts. This rich heritage was under threat of disappearing, both because of the physical decay and disintegration of the videotapes, and the ageing memories of the original community video practitioners. London Community Video Archive, a project based within Goldsmiths, University of London, is recovering and reviving this history so that it can be used as a resource for contemporary debates and activism.
Keywords: Elderly; Community Health Services; Social care
Locations: Brighton and Hove
Related
Comments